Saturday, July 9, 2011

National Association of Black Journalists Berates CNN

The National Association of Black Journalists issued a letter to CNN complaining about the same issue many of you have mentioned in ATC's comments, the lack of minorities in CNN's prime time lineup. We thought it might be a good jump off point for this weeks discussion. Take time to read the letter, it's after the bump, and give us your opinion.



Dear Friends:

It has been 17 days since I sent network news executives an open letter about the deplorable lack of diversity in their prime-time schedules. Now, I am floored that CNN missed another opportunity to fill a void created at 8 p.m. The NAACP took notice too and blasted the network for a lack of black talent on the desk after former New York governor Eliot Spitzer's departure this week. Former CNBC anchor Erin Burnett will join the prime-time lineup. This is no slight against Burnett, who has worked as a financial analyst and anchored financial news.

But this is not the first time CNN has had an opportunity and failed to diversify its nighttime lineup. During the past two years alone, CNN has made several changes after the departures of Lou Dobbs, Larry King, and Campbell Brown. With each of those changes came an opportunity for diversity; yet in each instance, CNN went in another direction.

Exacerbating the issue is the fact that CNN has several times passed over its own qualified African American journalists for prime-time posts in favor of whites who possess celebrity (Piers Morgan) or infamy (Spitzer). He resigned his post as New York governor in 2008 after an FBI sting revealed a liaison with a prostitute. In October 2010, NABJ met with CNN executives, including President Jim Walton, after the network announced that Morgan would replace Larry King upon his retirement. At the time, CNN said it was looking for the "right person" and not necessarily a mainstream journalist when the next prime-time opening occurred.

NABJ spoke out again when the network hired Spitzer and Kathleen Parker to replace Campbell Brown.

NABJ Vice President of Broadcast Bob Butler and I talked with Walton late Thursday, and he told us the network continues to seek and develop a candidate who has the image and substance to carry a prime-time show. I invited Walton to mount an innovative search during the NABJ national convention next month in Philadelphia. It will be packed with outstanding African American talent.

Since our meeting last year, CNN has made progress in hiring diverse executives including managing editor and executive vice president Mark Whitaker, CNNPolitics.com editor and former NABJ president Bryan Monroe, and Chief Marketing Officer Janet Rolle, who had a similar role at BET. In fact, NABJ sent Walton a letter thanking him for hiring Whitaker and for adding Suzanne Malveaux to the lineup of midday anchors. Walton said he is proud of the senior level hires, but until a person of color is added to prime time, CNN's progress will be "hollow." Viewers do not see who's making decisions or writing scripts.

NABJ sincerely hopes the next time there is an opening for a prime-time host, CNN will have found -- and groomed - the "right person." CNN must make efforts to ensure that its staff, both on-air and behind the scenes, is as diverse and inclusive as its audience.

Yours in service,

Kathy Y. Times
President
National Association of Black Journalists






All content, unless otherwise cited, is © All Things CNN and may not be used without consent of the blog administrator.

22 comments:

  1. Walton said 'The network continues to seek and develop a candidate who has the image and substance to carry a prime-time show'. Wow, if that's not a slap in the face for Soledad, TJ, Don Lemon and others I don't know what is.
    I don't think Walton has a clue what viewers want. It seems that most, if not all, of CNN's decision makers are out of touch with the average viewer.

    Personally I'd love to see CNN do a Newsroom type show at 10 PM. Lemon would be my first choice but there are many others at CNN who could make it work too. Nothing too in-depth, just an overview of the big stories of the day around the world.

    ReplyDelete
  2. There are far more critical areas in this great United States that the NAACP should be addressing.

    I don't think the NAACP would even care if the chosen anchor of color was qualified and a ratings winner, as long as their statistic was filled.

    They aren't saying anything about the fact that anchors of color are on the entire weekends at CNN.

    This just goes to show you just how trivial the NAACP truly is.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jim Walton will come to regret that comment.
    That is a slap in the face to Tj, Don & other
    minority journalists at CNN. If you look at
    CNN in prime time lately how in the hell
    does Eliot Spitzer and Piers Morgan help
    the image of CNN.He basically called Isha,
    Don, Tj, & others inferior. It is true CNN is
    run by bigots.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Jim Walton is being defensive because the
    knows there is no excuse for looking over
    qualified minority journalists in favor of
    Piers Morgan or Eliot Spitzer.

    I don't care if you are white, Latino, black,
    Asian, Native American, etc. Any human
    being should be appalled at a boneheaded
    racist comment like that. At first I gave CNN
    the benefit of the doubt but not any more.

    That explains why CNN totally disrespects
    President Obama.

    Boycott CNN and all of their shows and that
    includes 360.

    ReplyDelete
  5. CNN certainly does need more diversity on the network. There are very few African Americans, Asians, Latinos in prominent positions there. I see more people of color on MSNBC, not necessarily in prime time, but at least Tamron Hall has her own program there and they employ many African Americans as commentators, such as Kelli Goff and Toure, Jonathan Capehart, Melissa Harris-Perry and Eugene Washington. CNN barely has any female African American reporters/correspondents aside from Soledad and Suzanne Malveaux.
    Don Lemon is not a favorite of mine, but I think he's capable of handling more than weekend shifts where they seem to stick most of their African American reporters (Fredericka Whitfield has been doing weekends for EONS there). The lack of diversity at CNN is rather startling, IMO.

    ReplyDelete
  6. So let me get this straight. Soledad,Don,Tj,
    Isha, Suzanne and others are not as qualified
    to do breaking news in prime time as Eliot
    Spitzer and Piers Morgan. Phebe ;you are so
    right. So minorities are not a good image for
    CNN but Eliot Spitzer and Piers Morgan do
    no harm to CNN. Sure. Take a look at ratings.
    Let's see if Jim Walton takes the challenge.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anyone who believes the NAACP is "trivial" has probably never experienced the kind of racism that everyone would like to pretend is no longer a part of this nation because we have an African American President. The NAACP still is a significant organization to people of color who face racism and discrimination in housing/hiring/health care and they are very much needed today. Racism persists and it rears its ugly head in even the most unexpected places as I'm seeing now.

    ReplyDelete
  8. That explains why CNN totally disrespects
    President Obama.


    Without a doubt.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Yes I do absolutely believe and feel that the NAACP is trivial.
    And anyone who believes that CNN has an issue with hiring people of color truly does not watch CNN.

    The reason I feel NAACP is trivial because there are far greater fights in this country like housing, loans, schools. Areas that truly are a problem for people of all color. As opposed to making sure there is a person of color in primetime, really?

    You that are complaining if you actually watch CNN, you will see they are one of the better news organizations when it comes to people of color. You couldn't truly watch CNN because if you did then you would know CNN caters to Obama and gives him more air time than any other news outlet.

    And yes, I can truly speak from experience when it comes to NAACP, when it comes to a real issue, they are nothing more than a talking head not willing to go out on a limb for the average person. Only picking and choosing issues that will get media space.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I am not in a position to speak about people of color, but I think, if you read between Walton's lines, as Phebe quoted him, he's speaking of "a person of color who will get him ratings."
    Soledad had a morning slot with AC, back in 2003 and we just said our good-byes to Tony Harris.
    So they are not racists.
    It is and always was RATINGS.
    BLACK, WHITE, ASIAN, WHATEVER.
    I love Harris Faulkner on Fox News.
    She reminds me a bit of Isha on 360
    but Harris has been around a very long time on Fox and now has a Sunday show. She used to just read the bulletin and she worked herself up to an anchoring position in Atlanta and then was promoted to a weekly Sunday show.
    CNN could go in the opposite direction and DEMOTE MORGAN AND PUT DON LEMON in prime. It can't hurt.

    ReplyDelete
  11. NABJ is not the NAACP. It and other journalist
    organizations, Rachel Sklar and many others have
    written and spoken about this issue, If you never
    even let Don Lemon or Tj Holmes sit in the chair
    in prime time how can you say they won't get
    ratings. Have you seen CNN's ratings lately. CNN
    is making some dumb decisions.I take it that
    Jim Walton has never watched PMT. He can't carry
    a prime show or do a decent interview. There you
    go again CNN. All you have to do is watch CNN
    in prime time and you know this is bs.CNN has
    botched this big time. Any chance of Erin
    Burnett succeeding is gone. Walton just ruined
    any chance of CNN coming back. You just
    can't get away with what he said and expect
    viewers to watch CNN. The network gave
    Eliot Spitzer the lead show in prime time.
    CNN has no standards or values.As many
    have said before he didn't have to give the
    go ahead to Parker/Spitzer, ITA & PMT.
    Out of touch indeed. It sounds like Walton
    is too afraid that Don or TJ will prove him
    wrong.CNN. The Chicken News Network.
    I hear a Worst Person's coming and on
    The Last Word not too long ago Lawrence
    talked about this.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Guys, let's be fair to Isha. She is very much a
    part of 360. That is the last show you need
    to stop watching. I have never seen Anderson
    treat Isha or Joe Johns as less than equals, He
    clearly respects them both. Yes, there should
    be more diversity in prime time on cable but
    you can't overlook Isha;s role on 360. Ratings
    is also an issue with AM. CNN has problems
    all over the place. I don't envy Jim Walton at
    all. The man is trying to save a sinking ship.
    It is going to take a whole lot of time to fix
    CNN and get the network competitive again.

    ReplyDelete
  13. That is exactly why CNN should do a series of
    promos for the show announcing the move to
    8 featuring Charlie Moore Anderson Cooper,
    Isha Sesay, Joe johns, Dr. Sanjay Gupta, Gary
    Tuchman and all of Team 360. Have them to
    speak with CNN viewers about the time change
    and let Anderson have the last words about
    the move. The man has some writing skills.
    Use All The Young Dudes for a promo song.
    Carry the news about the time change.

    Remember many are not now watching CNN
    at 8 PM they don't anything about the move.
    Viewers have chosen 360 as their favorite
    CNN show and CNN should thank them in
    the promos and talk to them about the move
    and invite them to tune in at 8 PM.

    ReplyDelete
  14. The NAACP has never been, is not now and never will be "trivial" for any reason whatsoever.

    I think Isha would be great in a more prominent role at CNN.

    ReplyDelete
  15. @1:24PM: "use the Young Dudes," for a promo song and "CNN should thank viewers?"
    Really? Let's have a reality check here.
    When has CNN EVER thanked their viewers, about anything, let alone watching a show???
    Not a realistic venture on your part. Sorry.
    And it is up to viewers to KNOW when 360 is on. Yes, promotion of the move is necessary and I'm sure it will come, sooner or later, but those that have a vested interest in watching 360 will watch, just as before. As those who never watched, never will.
    It's called a following. Some will be inclined to catch AC at 10PM because of routine and scheduling.
    Others will DVR the program.
    But a song...NO.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Don Lemon handles breaking news all of the time
    on the weekends. It is not like he has zero live tv
    experience or lack actual news experience. There
    is no other way to say it. The management at CNN
    gambled away the network and lost badly. Stevie
    Wonder could see this a mile away. How does
    hiring a disgraced politician and a fired British
    tabloid editor who was let go for publishing
    fake photos improve the image of CNN or add
    substance to the network ? Open mouth and
    insert foot. The arrogance of CNN. They really
    do believe they can trick viewers and get away
    with it. No way man. We aren't that stupid.
    CNN wounds are self-inflicted and they still
    don't get it.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Maybe it is time for CNN to change their
    tune. CNN has to find ways to appreciate
    their viewers and let them know it. 360
    could not get those ratings without the
    viewers. Networks all ways do this. It's
    nothing new.

    ReplyDelete
  18. CNN has no clue. They are still going with a
    celebrity interview for 1 hour in prime tine
    with a lousy host who mumbles and stumbles
    so badly you can't understand one word Piers
    Morgan is saying. CNN sure does need to drop
    PMT but they won't. CNN definitely fits Albert
    Einstein's definition of insanity. They keep
    trying the same thing over and over again
    hoping for a different result. Not gonna happen.
    We get bombarded with those annoying PMT
    promos but none from all of the news people
    on CNN. I say do the news promos with
    Anderson, journalists and staff. Not pundits
    CNN is suppose to be a news channel. Where
    are the reporter promos. Let me get this
    straight. A news channel does not promote
    real journalists. Something is wrong with
    this picture.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Oh No he didn't. Jim Walton used image and
    substance in the same sentence when talking
    about CNN. Dude don't go there. Realize that
    Mad Men is just a show and not 2011 America.
    It's okay to have minorities in prime time on
    CNN. Americans won't be afraid like you are.
    Minorities are not exactly invisible these days.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Mr. Walton please hire George Stroumboulopoulos.
    He can do an hour of news and interview show live
    with a studio audience. Strombo even does docs
    He does this in Canada. Can we get this show
    in the U.S. Just take a look online.

    ReplyDelete
  21. CNN is going to be picked apart by their
    competition for having the former editor
    for News Of The World on their payroll.
    Now there is news the tabloid tried to
    hack 9/11 victims. Another disaster is
    coming up for CNN when it comes to
    recent hires. I wonder how long it will
    be before people stop talking to him.
    because of New Of The World. This is
    the man responsible for bringing this
    tabloid journalist to America. Thanks
    for nothing Jim Walton.LOL.

    ReplyDelete
  22. CNN should try to bring back Tony Harris...but I guess that is not going to happen. Suzanne Malvieus is ok, but please get rid of that
    "you pick the story" segment....the
    time wasted "shillng" the stories coould be better spent by showing them. Some days all three sound
    intesting.i

    ReplyDelete

When commenting please keep in mind...

* We welcome all comments as long as they are respectful to CNN personalities, the bloggers and other commenters.

* Comments that include links to other websites will not be posted without prior approval of the moderator.

* If you have a tip or some news please send it to our address, listed on the sidebar, along with your source. You will be credited (with your permission) if we use the information.

* All comments are posted at the discretion of the moderator.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.